This book by Jana Wolff, more than anything, has helped me start to wrap my mind around what adoption entails. Even though she went through open domestic adoption, and we would be going through the State, her raw, open account of the emotional turmoil that is adoption is inspiring. Some people feel that this book is too raw, too painful. But I need that kind of brutal honesty before I can face my fears. And for that, I thank this author with all my heart. Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of the heartwarming moments you expect in the book, but she doesn't go all Hallmark on it.
Jana and her husband turned to adoption after failed infertility treatments. We have that in common. We also have in common (or so it appears) a love for the complete, unvarnished truth in written word. So I definitely identified with her. She also addresses many of the emotional roadblocks discussed in Unsung Lullabies. I found it very helpful to read that book first.
I find that I seem to have a love/hate relationship with adoption. I had always imagined that if I chose adoption, it would have been my choice after biological children or knowing that I could have biological children if I wanted. Now that I find myself backed into a corner by infertility, that choice is not filled with all the sunshine and rainbows I had imagined before. I felt like Jana reached into my brain and put into a book what I would have said if I had it figured out. One touching chapter features an imaginary letter to the birth mother with all those true, conflicted thoughts represented. Next to that, she writes the real letter that went with their file; the one that contains all the flattering words she thinks (and sometimes does) feel. It was such an illuminating moment for me.
When Jana and her husband do go to bring their baby home, her account of the birth was gut wrenching. It addressed all those fears I had tucked into my back pocket. Will the baby be healthy? Will the mother want him back? Will I love him right away? Will I feel like backing out? What if the baby looks so different from us that everyone stares? How do I prepare mentally for a child without experiencing the pregnancy? Will my family accept him equally?
These are all questions that may sound trite to one who has never really been faced with the reality that adoption may be their only chance. Frankly, I don't want to hear one peep from those people that I'm a bad person for thinking these things. Face it yourself, then you can talk.
The last third of the book completely switches gears, but it was an interesting and welcome switch. Jana talks about the fact that they are white and Jewish, while their child comes from a Christian, Hispanic mother and a mixed race father. I read this section with hungry eyes. Even if I never faced these issues, the insidious, "quiet" racism that still exists in this country is a fascinating subject for me. Furthermore, even if we do conceive a biological child (looking more doubtful after 2 years), our child will be mixed race as well. He or she will most likely look very much like a slightly less obvious version of the Hub. As much as I look forward to that, I also often wonder if people will assume I've adopted my biological child, or how I will help him or her understand that though we are moving toward more equality in numbers and treatment, that trend has plateaued somewhat. We are at the point of diminishing returns. There is progress, but it's glacial. How do I tell him or her to answer when someone asks, "What are you?" It's a seemingly innocent question right? But it's filled with so much undertone when asked from majority to minority.
I devoured this book. I highly recommend it. If you're in the place right now where you need purely uplifting adoption stories, then don't read it. Wait until you need to understand some of the pain that goes along with it. Otherwise, go for it. You won't regret it. My only suggestion is to read Unsung Lullabies first, as it will help you understand yourself AND Jana.
Here are some of the chapter titles just to give you a feel for the book:
1. To Produce or Purchase?
Either way, it's gonna cost.
3. The Home Study: Mr. & Mrs. Perfect
Your house will never (and need never) be this clean again.
5. Expecting Without Pregnancy
Buy the crib, but hang on to the receipt.
8. Show Time
Labor and deliverance.
9. If this is the Happiest Day of My Life, Why am I so Sad?
The myth of bliss.
12. The Name Game
Should we name him after my family, your family or her family?
14. Saying Goodbye
Even the right decision can feel wrong.
18. Spit- Up is Spit-Up
Adopted poop doesn't smell any different.
20. Should We Send Cute or Ugly Pictures?
Will she want him back when she sees those dimples?
24. Friendly Racism
Are they staring, or am I paranoid?
Tuesday, March 18, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
15 comments:
Thank you for your very honest review of this book. I am looking forward to reading your thoughts as you process the issues of adoption.
SHe sounds like my kind of woman! I respect honest, raw poeple.
Thank you for the sweet comments you leave on my blog. I am honored that you are able to still at times read my posts.
I will going out tomorrow to purchase this book, I really identified with alot of things you wrote about identifying with. I look to resolve (as much as possible) my feelings about IF and I completely agree about your comment and the choice of adoption versus it being the only option left.
Thanks for you kind message, wish we lived closer. I'm looking forward to reading your blog in the future!
Nice review Barb. I'm glad that you've found so much support from these books.
I totally understand why you would have concerns about attachment, family acceptance, social acceptance etc. It would be foolish not to consider them, when they would be your reality.
Maybe I'm naive, but I think our society is somewhat advanced when it comes to blended race families etc. It's so common now that it's no longer a shocker, is it?
Of course there will always be rude people, no matter what.
It has now been added to my Amazon wish list. Once I get another book or two to get me to the free shipping threshold (which historically speaking isn't more than a few weeks) it will be on it's way to me. I looooovvvvveeee unbrazen honesty as well.
P.S. I'm currently working my way through The Baby Business: How Money, Science, and Politics Drive the Commerce of Conception and it is FABULOUS - I highly recommend it!
Stephanie, I'm afraid I have to disagree with you on the mixed race thing. There are wide swaths of the country (US) where the only familiarty people have with non-white folks is from watching the evening news. Believe me, it's still a shocker. You'd be horrified at the assumptions people make about you if you're obviously non-white.
Barb, this sounds like a great read. I can no longer afford to adopt, although like you I always assumed I'd have the choice (the dream was to have 'my own children' and then adopt one or two more). Thanks to IVF I have a baby now, but what's interesting is how much in common there is between adoptive and birth parents (and by birth parents, I mean, 'this woman carried and gave birth to this child' regardless of whether or not the child was adopted out)?
Maybe it's because I'm a clueless new parent, or because I'm infertile, but I find myself drawn to adoption blogs of new parents, too. Perhaps I'm wrong in thinking this, but a child suddenly appearing in one's life is such a shock, and there's so much 'oh wait, I asked for this, right?' involved, that I just can't help but think we're all in this together no matter how the child comes into our lives.
Well, that was enough of a ramble - hope it makes sense!
PS: my son takes after his father, leading me to think I'm in for a lifetime of 'So when did you adopt him?' questions, the same ones that my mother got after I was born. Ah well, maybe he'll darken a little bit as he gets older...looks like the afro isn't happening, though!
Wow! What a great response to this! Thanks ladies!
And you're welcome bstbs and Kara. I will be following you too. :)
You're welcome too Farah. It's just the truth. I read your blog almost every day if I can.
Stephanie! Thanks for the support chickie! And I have to agree with both you AND Oro. While I do think our society (particularly the younger set) is more open to interracial couples and more advanced in their thinking, at the same time, it strongly depends on where you are in the country. My old home STILL rarely sees anything other than WASPs. It was a really big to do when we had a Catholic family move into our school. You should see how they look at DH sometimes. It isn't nastiness most of the time, just a supreme ignorance and fascination.
Cool Freyja! I'll check it out! :)
Let me know when you read the book.
Oro - Too funny. In a weird way, that gives me hope that if we DO have bio children, they'll look SOMETHING like me. He's the dark one so I always imagined it would be mostly him. He's got the dominant genes. :) I really do want them to pick up most of his traits as I find him gorgeous.. of course, but I'd like to see me a little too.
I'm sorry IF took away some of your options. It sucks monkey balls.
barb - you wrote:
"Will the baby be healthy? Will the mother want him back? Will I love him right away? Will I feel like backing out? What if the baby looks so different from us that everyone stares? How do I prepare mentally for a child without experiencing the pregnancy? Will my family accept him equally?
These are all questions that may sound trite to one who has never really been faced with the reality that adoption may be their only chance. Frankly, I don't want to hear one peep from those people that I'm a bad person for thinking these things. Face it yourself, then you can talk."
OMG, that was so right on it stopped me in my tracks.
this is SUCH an amazing post. i have finished unsung lullabies - and like how you feel about jana's book, i felt like UL's writers stuck electrodes in my brain and put all of its contents into their book. i suspect i'll feel similar to jana's book. that will be my next read.
after 2.5 years of this fruitless journey, i too am finding the transition from hoping i will have a biological child to letting go and moving on to adoption to be both promising and gut wrenching at the same time. some days i can't tell my head from my ass.
i wish we could meet in IRL. i have a feeling we'd be fast friends.
xoxo
Barb, thank you so much for sharing your review. It really hit home on a lot of points. We're getting to a point where we'll be deciding between adoption and IVF. I've been leaning towards adoption but of course I have my fears about it. I'm reading "Unsung Lullabies" now but this looks like a good one to move on to. I also prefer the real story, I don't need a Hallmark card at this point!
Also thanks so much for the comments on my blog. :) I had to smile after reading what you said about the family at the restaurant. I certainly hoped that I wasn't being rude (I tried to be rather surreptitious with my glances!)... in reality, I was trying to picture us over there.
Hi! I have those same thoughts on adoption. It definately is a different feeling when you are faced with having to adopt to have children versus choosing to. I would rather have the choice too. Thanks for the review on the book. I'm always looking for new books to read.
Thanks for stopping by my blog. I'm glad you are doing well lately...i hope it continues. :)
It sounds like this book was really helpful for you. I appreciate the fact that her story wasn't candy coated and presented facts the way they are. I'm glad you are finding some good reading material to help you sort through your feelings. I always find it helpful when making tough decisions too.
Fantastic review and discussion of adoption. Like you, I look for the "unvarnished truth." Happy endings are nice but usually not believable. I want something REAL.
I think I may pick up that book. Adoption is something we are considering down the road (assuming that Little Life is in it for the long haul) so I don't yet need all happy stories to keep me interested in it as an option.
I appreciate your honesty as well. People need to talk about their ambivalence. Clear, one-dimensional feelings almost NEVER happen. Even with pregnancy after fertility treatments (which is, perhaps, one of the dirtiest little secrets.)
XOXO
You've inspired me to check out this book. I've decided if we're going to adopt I want to do it with eyes wide open, unlike this whole IF deal. It sounds like this is that kind of book. Thank you for such a detailed review.
Barb - I have to tell you that I purchased "Secret Thoughts of an Adoptive Mother" last night and I'am already 1/2 way through it. Very well written and so spot on with my emotions and thoughts. Jana has an excellent way of conveying the brutal reality of truth and still maintaining a sense of humor.
I have Unsung lullabies on order, Thanks so much for these fantastic resources.
Woo hoo! Thanks for the update Kara. :) I read it really quickly too.
Post a Comment